A venue that decides Europe means professionals only has settled a question about its audience, not the one that decides whether the plan works: how a particular person becomes a professional. Annex II to Directive 2014/65/EU, the law the industry calls MiFID II, does not describe a status a user can claim. It describes an assessment the firm has to perform and stand behind, a floor of hard criteria underneath it, and three written statements, one of which cannot sit inside the contract the user has already accepted. We have written before that narrowing the audience to professionals does not remove the obligation to hold a licence. This is the other half of that plan: the audience is built one person at a time, in the part of onboarding that self-service exists to remove.
One sentence refuses to presume anything about the people who opt up
Annex II has two halves. Section I makes professionals of institutions by identity, from authorised financial firms to governments and central banks, and nobody in it proves anything about their own trading. Section II covers everyone who has to earn the label, and names them: "public sector bodies, local public authorities, municipalities and private individual investors". A human reading a prediction market screen is in Section II or nowhere.
The second paragraph of Section II then contains the line a product plan has to read twice. Firms may treat Section II clients as professionals if the criteria and procedure are satisfied, and the annex adds that those clients "shall not, however, be presumed to possess market knowledge and experience comparable to that of the categories listed in Section I".
Ireland transposed MiFID II through the European Union (Markets in Financial Instruments) Regulations 2017, and paragraph 4(2) of Schedule 2 to S.I. No. 375 of 2017 carries that sentence almost word for word. Professionals only, then, is not a synonym for sophisticated. It is one label over two populations with nothing in common, and the law itself tells the firm not to confuse them.
Two of three criteria is a floor under an assessment, not a substitute for one
A waiver of retail protection, says Annex II, is "valid only if an adequate assessment of the expertise, experience and knowledge of the client, undertaken by the investment firm, gives reasonable assurance, in light of the nature of the transactions or services envisaged, that the client is capable of making investment decisions and understanding the risks involved". Reasonable assurance is a judgement somebody forms and records.
The familiar criteria come next, and the words introducing them are the ones summaries drop: "In the course of that assessment, as a minimum, two of the following criteria shall be satisfied". Those criteria are transactions in significant size on the relevant market averaging ten per quarter over the previous four quarters, a financial instrument portfolio "defined as including cash deposits and financial instruments" exceeding EUR 500 000, or at least one year in a professional position in the financial sector requiring knowledge of the services envisaged. They sit inside the assessment, they do not replace it, and they oblige nobody. A client who clears two of three has met the floor; the firm decides whether it has reasonable assurance, and may decide it does not. A flow that promotes whoever clears two boxes has turned the floor into the ceiling.
Significant size is the number the directive never wrote down
Neither Annex II, nor the Irish Schedule, nor the German transposition defines "significant size", and none defines "the relevant market" either. For a contract that pays a fixed amount or nothing and trades between zero and one, neither phrase has an obvious reading. Ten positions of twenty euros in a quarter are ten transactions; whether they are ten transactions in significant size is a question each firm answers itself, and as of 5 November 2026 we could find no published European figure filling the gap.
Annex II does require firms to "implement appropriate written internal policies and procedures to categorise clients", so the number exists somewhere in every authorised firm. The only variable is whether the venue wrote it before the first upgrade request or after a supervisor asked for it.
Three statements, and one of them cannot sit in the contract
The procedure in Section II.2 is three steps in sequence. The client must "state in writing to the investment firm that they wish to be treated as a professional client". The firm "must give them a clear written warning of the protections and investor compensation rights they may lose". Then the client must "state in writing, in a separate document from the contract, that they are aware of the consequences of losing such protections". Only then may the firm decide, and first it must "take all reasonable steps to ensure" the criteria are met.
The third step is where a click through flow fails on the text rather than on the spirit. A tick box inside the terms and conditions is in the contract by definition, and so is a consolidated acceptance screen. The separation exists so that the one document in which a user gives up protection is a document they had to look at on its own.
Germany lets the firm start the conversation and Ireland pins the cut-off date
The same test takes visibly different shapes in national law, a pattern this category has met before in the national answers on what counts as a financial instrument. Section 67(6) of the German Securities Trading Act, the Wertpapierhandelsgesetz, says a retail client may be classified as professional "auf Antrag oder durch Festlegung des Wertpapierdienstleistungsunternehmens", on request or by determination of the firm. Annex II contemplates only a client request; German law lets the firm initiate.
The German text then requires a written warning that retail protections under the Act cease to apply, and written confirmation from the client that the warning was noted. It does not itself repeat the directive's separate document wording, and section 67(7) empowers the Federal Ministry of Finance to specify the procedure by regulation. Section 67(6) closes with something the directive does not say at all: where a professional client fails to report changes affecting the classification, a misclassification resting on that silence is no breach of duty by the firm. Ireland tightened instead, limiting the grandfathering of older categorisations in paragraph 5(3) of its Schedule to clients categorised "before 3 January 2018", where the directive carries no date at all.
The warning has to name the compensation rights, not only the conduct rules
The annex asks for a warning about two distinct things, "the protections and investor compensation rights they may lose". Investor compensation is a national scheme, funded and capped nationally, so a venue cannot draft the warning until it knows which scheme covers its clients and what the cover is worth. That also makes it the only mandatory explanation in the flow, the one place where European law requires a venue to say plainly what is being taken away. A warning written as a disclaimer wastes the only teaching moment the process guarantees, which is what our fourth directive is about.
Once the gate is behind you, the law lets the firm assume you know
Article 56(1) of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, which fills in MiFID II's conduct rules, says "an investment firm shall be entitled to assume that a professional client has the necessary experience and knowledge in order to understand the risks involved in relation to those particular investment services or transactions, or types of transaction or product, for which the client is classified as a professional client". Article 54(3) grants a parallel assumption for suitability.
Read the two instruments together and the architecture is plain. Annex II withholds the presumption of knowledge from everyone who opts up; the delegated regulation hands it back the instant the opt-up succeeds, and the appropriateness test, which would otherwise ask under Article 55(1)(b) about "the nature, volume, and frequency of the client's transactions in financial instruments and the period over which they have been carried out", stops in the way. That is the design rather than a loophole, and it is what makes professional service workable at all. But it makes the assessment at the gate load-bearing in a way few onboarding steps are. It is not one control among several, it is the control that all the others were traded away for.
A firm may rely on what a client says until its own records say otherwise
Self-attestation is not forbidden. Article 55(3) says a firm "shall be entitled to rely on the information provided by its clients or potential clients unless it is aware or ought to be aware that the information is manifestly out of date, inaccurate or incomplete". For a trading venue, that second clause takes back rather a lot.
A venue holds its users' order history. If a user attests to ten transactions of significant size per quarter and the venue's own books show nothing resembling it, the firm is not relying in good faith on client information. It is sitting on the contradiction, in its own database, timestamped. The screen that collected the attestation has quietly produced the best available evidence that the attestation went untested. This is why the opt-up belongs in the category our third directive describes, a protection built into the product rather than a form.
The answer for the user who does not pass has to be a product, not an apology
A user who fails stays retail, and for this category that is not a reduced service level, it is a closed door. In its public statement of 3 July 2026, numbered ESMA35-243228190-8148, the European Securities and Markets Authority wrote that "the marketing, distribution or sale to retail clients of event contracts that meet the definition of financial instruments is prohibited", a reminder it published the same day. Only contracts whose event question relates to an underlying in Section C(4) to (10) of MiFID II's Annex I are financial instruments, and the two exemptions from the ban do not fit a yes or no contract.
So the correct answer to a failed assessment is nothing, and nothing has to be designed: a screen that says no and explains why, a route that does not loop the user back into a gentler version of the same questions, and a record of the decision. Interactive Brokers Ireland's Retail Client Categorisation Notification, a copy of which the broker Lynx publishes in full, tells each client it has been categorised as a Retail Client, says the firm "initially categorises all clients as Retail Clients", and directs anyone wanting a different answer to "initiate a request from the Client Portal" with "the information and supporting documentation to enable us to comprehensively consider your request". The protected category is the default, and the burden of moving sits with whoever wants to.
A categorisation nobody revisits is a categorisation that expires quietly
Annex II does not treat the opt-up as a one-time event. "Professional clients are responsible for keeping the investment firm informed about any change, which could affect their current categorisation," it says, and then, should the firm "become aware however that the client no longer fulfils the initial conditions, which made him eligible for a professional treatment, the investment firm shall take appropriate action".
Two things therefore have to exist that no onboarding flow contains: a downgrade path with a named owner and a trigger, and a decision about what counts as becoming aware, because a venue watching trading frequency for risk purposes is already watching what the first criterion measures. A venue that upgraded a user on a 2026 portfolio figure and never looked again holds a classification accurate on exactly one day.
The easier test was agreed in Brussels and is still not law
All of the above describes the test in force on 5 November 2026, and that test is already scheduled to loosen. In a note of 23 December 2025 the law firm Loyens & Loeff reads the provisional deal on the Retail Investment Strategy as replacing the EUR 500 000 figure with an average portfolio above EUR 250 000 over three years, replacing the quarterly transaction test with fifteen significant transactions over three years or thirty in the preceding year, and adding an education route that may not be combined with the portfolio criterion. Where the file stands is worth stating exactly. The European Parliament's own procedure file for "Retail investor protection rules", 2023/0167(COD) records approval in committee of the negotiated text on 23 June 2026, gives an indicative plenary sitting of 11 November 2026, and still shows the status as awaiting Parliament's position in first reading. The European Commission is blunter about the timetable in its request to ESMA for technical advice, fisma.c.3(2026)6598499, signed on 30 July 2026: Official Journal publication "should occur at the latest in January 2027", member states then have 24 months to transpose, and firms "will have to apply the provisions of the legal text as from July 2029".
Two and a half years, which means anyone designing a European opt-up flow designs it against EUR 500 000 and a four quarter lookback. Britain, having left the directive, moved in the opposite direction and has not landed either. The Financial Conduct Authority published consultation paper CP25/36 on client categorisation on 8 December 2025, proposing to drop the quantitative test for elective professional clients other than local authorities, and closed it to comment on 2 February 2026. As of 5 November 2026 its page for the paper promises only a policy statement once the responses are reviewed. In both jurisdictions the rule governing a venue onboarding a user this week is the old one.
What a venue that means this would write down first
The opt-up cannot be retrofitted, because the evidence it needs is generated at onboarding and nowhere else. Six things have to exist before the first user sees the flow.
- The written categorisation policy Annex II requires, including the venue's own definition of significant size and of the relevant market for a binary contract.
- The assessment itself, recorded as a judgement rather than a tally.
- The warning, naming both the conduct protections and the investor compensation rights under the applicable national scheme.
- The acknowledgement as a separate artefact from the customer agreement.
- The refusal path, including what the user sees and what the venue keeps.
- The downgrade trigger, with an owner.
Our fifth directive asks that standards be set against the jurisdiction that regulates next rather than the one that has not yet. Here that jurisdiction has written the standard down already and is in the middle of making it easier. A venue that builds the harder version now will not rebuild it in 2029. If that is the floor your firm wants this category to stand on, the commitment is public and open to signature.