Rule 5.10 of the Polymarket US rulebook dated 30 September 2026 contains one sentence that reads like housekeeping. The company will post on its website the pricing, current volume and open interest for all active contracts on each trading day, and will also post any other information required by CFTC Regulation 16.01. Rule 2.17(b) of the KalshiEX LLC rulebook, version 1.31 makes a parallel promise in its own words: Kalshi shall make public on a daily basis information on settlement prices, volume, open interest, and opening and closing ranges for actively traded contracts.
Behind both sentences sits one federal regulation, and it asks a question that is easy to misread. Not whether a file was produced, but whether the information was made readily available to a named audience. Those are different tests, and a venue can pass the first while failing the second without anyone noticing: nothing bounces and nobody complains. On 20 November 2026 we went looking for the files both promises point at.
What Part 16 asks an exchange to hand over, and to whom
Commission Regulation 16.01, adopted at 77 FR 36696 on 19 June 2012 and amended at 77 FR 66333 on 2 November 2012, works in three movements. Paragraph (a) tells a reporting market what to record for each business day: total gross open contracts, total trading volume excluding transfer and office trades, the volume exchanged for commodities or for derivatives positions, and the volume of block trades included in that total. Paragraph (b) does the same for prices, including opening and closing prices, the price used for settlement if it differs from the closing price, and the extremes of sales, bids and offers that the market reasonably determines reflect conditions.
Paragraph (d) then sets the clock for the regulator. The Commission must have the delta factor and settlement price by 7:00 a.m. on the following business day, and the rest by 12:00 p.m. Paragraph (e) sets the obligation to everyone else, and it decides whether any of this reaches a reader.
The free clause covers volume and stops before prices
Read the two subparagraphs of paragraph (e) next to each other and they are not the same sentence twice. Subparagraph (e)(1), which governs the paragraph (a) data, requires that the information be made readily available to the news media and the general public without charge, in a format that readily enables the consideration of such data, no later than the business day following. Subparagraph (e)(2), which governs the price data in paragraphs (b)(2) and (b)(3), carries the same audience, the same format language and the same deadline, and the words without charge are not in it.
So the regulation draws a line that neither rulebook draws. Volume and open interest are free to everybody by rule. Prices must be available, and the text does not say free. There is a third door in the same paragraph: the method a market uses to determine nominal and settlement prices, in paragraph (b)(4)(i), has to live in the registered entity's rulebook, which paragraph (e)(2) describes as publicly accessible on its website. One regulation, three different standards of openness, keyed to three different kinds of number.
Note the asymmetry of hours. The regulator gets a time of day; the public gets a day.
Both rulebooks describe the duty without using its words
We counted phrases across the full text of both rulebooks as published, using our own extraction: 35,451 words for Polymarket US and 50,134 for Kalshi. The phrase without charge appears zero times in both. The phrase news media appears zero times in both. In a combined 85,585 words of exchange rules, the two expressions that define what a reader is owed are absent.
That is not a violation. Polymarket US incorporates the regulation by reference in the same breath, and a cross reference carries the duty perfectly well in law. It is a drafting choice with a consequence: a trader reading the rulebook cover to cover never meets the sentence saying the volume figures belong to them for nothing.
The Kalshi rulebook names Part 16 exactly once, in Rule 2.16 on recordkeeping and reporting, and it points the other way: Kalshi shall record and report to the CFTC all data required to be reported under Part 16. Its single use of general public is not about market data at all, but about keeping the annual schedule of disciplinary committee and arbitration panel members available. Both rulebooks do contain the operative phrase readily available, and in both it is aimed at regulators inspecting records rather than at anyone reading a website.
One more detail sits in Kalshi's Rule 3.1(b), which lists what a Self Clearing Member may do. Among the privileges is the right to view the current trading volume and open interest for contracts traded on the platform. Those are the same two data points that subparagraph (e)(1) makes free to the general public. In one document they are an entitlement of membership, and in the other they are a public good.
The file turned out to live in a footer that loads later
Fetch the Polymarket US homepage the way a script or a crawler would and the served document offers six internal destinations: the clearing site, a developers page, the rulebook, a market integrity page, a notices page and a regulatory page. None of them is the data. The strings daily-market-report and time-and-sales appear zero times in the served HTML of the homepage, the regulatory page, the notices page and the about page, all checked on 20 November 2026.
Open the same page in a browser and a footer appears carrying three new links: Daily Market Report, Time and Sales, and Block Trades. The mechanism is described by the site's own script. The file assets/js/includes.js introduces itself as client side HTML includes for static sites, loading header and footer components for the exchange, and it fetches them from a separate components directory at page load. The link to the data lives in a fragment that is not any page.
Nothing here looks deliberate; the fragment is plainly part of the site design. But subparagraph (e)(1) is written about reaching people, and the first audience it names is the news media. A reporter reading what the server sends, or an archiving tool, or a monitoring script, sees six links and no data.
What one business day of data actually contains
Behind that footer link the Daily Market Report page is in good shape, and that deserves saying plainly. It lists one file per business day as a plain CSV, 387 of them when we counted. The file for 18 November 2026 is 86.8 MB and holds 275,984 data rows across 21 columns, every row a distinct contract symbol carrying the same single business date.
The columns map onto the regulation closely: open interest, trade volume, block volume, exchange for physical volume, exchange for risk volume, low and high bid, low and high offer, low and high trade price, and settlement price. Our own totals over that file come to 397,571,640 contracts of trade volume and 210,795,180 contracts of open interest for the day, with block volume at zero. Just under ninety per cent of rows carried volume, two fifths carried open interest, and no row was empty on all three counts. The largest single contract by volume, 8,223,351 contracts, was a basketball market.
The timing is ahead of the requirement rather than behind it. The page states that it updates at approximately midnight Eastern time, and the 18 November file carried a modified timestamp of 02:44 UTC on 19 November, inside the deadline with room to spare. The Time and Sales page states that it updates at approximately 6:00 p.m. Eastern, and on the evening of 19 November the report for that same day was already listed. An exchange publishing intraday trade data on the day it happened is doing more than the rule asks.
The clause about keeping volume together is the one that passes
Subparagraph (e)(1) closes with a sentence that is easy to skip. The information in paragraphs (a)(2)(iv) through (vi), meaning total volume, the volume exchanged for commodities or derivatives positions, and block volume, shall be made readily available in a format that presents the information together. It is a rule against splitting one day's volume picture across three places.
In the Polymarket US file those four volume columns sit in the same row of the same CSV, so the clause is satisfied by construction rather than by effort. We point it out because this is the sort of sub clause that gets missed, and here it did not. A venue publishing volume as one row per contract has solved a problem that three separate dashboards would create.
A year filter that cannot select 2026
The same page carries two filter controls. The month control offers twelve months. The year control offers exactly two options: all years, and 2025. The list itself holds 387 daily files, the oldest dated 28 October 2025 and the newest 18 November 2026, and 322 of them fall in 2026. So the only year a reader can select is the one holding 65 files, and the year holding the other 322 cannot be chosen at all.
On its own this is a small bug on a page otherwise doing its job, and scrolling still works. It is worth a sentence because of where it lands: the test in subparagraph (e)(1) is a format that readily enables the consideration of such data, and a broken control is a format problem, not a cosmetic one.
Block trade data sits on a host named after institutions
The Polymarket US block trades page, effective 2 July 2026, sets a block threshold of 100,000 contracts for politics, macroeconomics and sports alike, with a fifteen minute reporting window, and states that executed block trades are published, identified as such, on the Block Trade Data page under Rule 5.3(m)(vi). That page is at a subdomain that titles itself Polymarket Institutional.
Two things are true about it. It opened without a login on 20 November 2026, so access is genuinely public, and it reported no block trades for that date, matching the zero block volume we summed out of the 18 November file. Two independent surfaces telling the same story is the outcome you want from a disclosure regime, and that is what happened here.
The remaining wrinkle is the sign over the door. Block trade volume is part of paragraph (a), which is the set that subparagraph (e)(1) makes free to the news media and the general public. Putting it on a host named for institutions says something about the expected reader that the regulation does not say. The point is about audience, not access, and it connects to how the same page frames position accountability.
Kalshi answers the same question through an open API
Kalshi's public trading interface answered without any authentication on 20 November 2026. The markets endpoint at api.elections.kalshi.com returns, for each market, fields named volume, twenty four hour volume and open interest, alongside bid, ask and last price. A basketball market with the ticker KXNBAGAME-26NOV19LACSAS-LAC carried a volume of 1,003,477.97, open interest of 908,507.09 and a last price of 0.1300 dollars when we read it.
So the numbers are there, free, machine readable, and arguably better formatted for consideration than an 87 MB file. The two exchanges answered the same clause with different trade offs: one publishes a complete daily archive that is hard to find and heavy to open, the other a live feed that is easy to query if you know the host name. A venue serious about Directive 02 would want both, because a daily file and a live endpoint answer different questions.
What we could not check, and why that belongs in the article
We did not reach the Kalshi website. Plain requests to kalshi.com from our environment returned HTTP 429, and a full browser received a Vercel security checkpoint page reading Failed to verify your browser. We therefore make no claim about whether Kalshi publishes a human readable daily report page, and we did not verify the opening and closing ranges that Rule 2.17(b) promises. We verified three of its four promised items through the API, and we are flagging the fourth as unchecked rather than missing.
That failure is not only our problem, though. A bot defence that turns away datacenter addresses is part of the answer to whether data is readily available to the news media, because much newsroom and research tooling runs from exactly those addresses. We are not suggesting the defence come down; scraping pressure on a venue like this is real. We are suggesting that an exchange with an anti bot wall needs a documented route through it for the audience the regulation names, which sits alongside the older problem of one volume line standing in for two regimes.
Five things that would make the duty visibly discharged
- One stable URL per report, linked from the HTML the server sends. If the only path to a required disclosure is injected by script after load, the disclosure depends on the reader's tooling.
- A page that names the rule it discharges. One line saying that the page exists under Regulation 16.01(e)(1) and that the data is free lets a reader check the promise against the duty without reading the rulebook.
- A summary file beside the bulk file. One row per day with exchange totals for volume, open interest and block volume. Nobody should have to sum 275,984 rows to learn what a day looked like.
- Controls that work on the data present. A year filter should offer the years in the list.
- A stated publication time with its time zone, plus a documented route for research and newsroom tools, so the anti bot layer and the transparency duty stop pulling against each other.
Publishing and being findable are two different achievements
The summary of this audit is that the substance is better than the signposting. The Polymarket US daily file is complete, machine readable, dated, early, and it satisfies a sub clause about presenting volume together that many venues would miss. Kalshi's volume and open interest are free to read by anyone who sends one unauthenticated request. Measured on whether the numbers exist and are public, both pass, which is a real improvement on a category whose structural detail has gone largely unreported.
Measured on the words the regulation uses, there is a gap. Readily available describes a relationship between a file and a person, not a property of the file. The last few metres of that relationship, a link in the served page, a working filter, a summary line, a name for the rule being satisfied, are cheap next to producing 275,984 rows a day. A category that wants to be trusted with public probability estimates should want the route to its own numbers to be the easiest part.